If you have ever watched someone flip a cup of frozen custard upside down and nothing falls out, you already know what Andy’s Custard is all about. Andy’s Frozen Custard has built its whole reputation on one thing: frozen custard made fresh every hour, blended thick with mix-ins, and served so dense it holds its shape. This guide to the andy’s custard menu covers every category on the 2026 menu — concretes, Jackhammers, sundaes, splits, shakes, malts, drinks, take-home pints and quarts, and the seasonal lineup — with reported prices and calories so you can decide what to order before you pull up to the drive-thru window.
A quick note on prices first, because it matters at Andy’s more than at most chains. Andy’s stores are independently owned and franchise-operated, and each store sets its own prices. That means the numbers in this guide are typical reported prices gathered from menu-tracking sites and delivery listings in November 2026 — not official prices from Andy’s itself. Two different sources can list the same concrete a dollar apart, and both can be right for their own towns. Treat every price below as a range to expect, and confirm the exact price at your local store before you order. The same goes for calories: the figures shown come from menu sites that publish Andy’s nutrition data, and they can vary slightly by size and mix-in.
What Is Andy’s Frozen Custard?
Andy’s Frozen Custard was founded on March 19, 1986, in Osage Beach, Missouri, by John and Carol Kuntz, who named the shop after their son Andy. The couple had first tasted frozen custard in Wisconsin and decided to bring the idea to the Lake of the Ozarks. The little shop at the lake became a local legend, then spread to nearby Springfield, Missouri, and from there across the Midwest and South.
Today Andy’s is the largest frozen-custard-only chain in the United States, with 192 locations across 15 states as of May 2026, according to Wikipedia — Arizona, Arkansas, Colorado, Florida, Georgia, Illinois, Kansas, Kentucky, Louisiana, Missouri, North Carolina, Oklahoma, South Carolina, Tennessee, and Texas. The chain is still headquartered in Springfield, Missouri, and it celebrated its 40th year in 2026.
What makes frozen custard different from regular ice cream is the recipe and the churn. Custard contains egg yolk (at least 1.4% by the legal definition), more butterfat than standard ice cream, and far less air, because it is churned slowly. The result is denser, creamier, and richer than soft serve, and it is served slightly warmer than ice cream, so the flavor comes through more strongly. At Andy’s, the custard is made fresh every hour in every store — vanilla and chocolate are the two base flavors, and everything else on the menu is built from them.
Unlike most dessert chains, Andy’s serves no food at all. There are no burgers, no fries, no chicken sandwiches. The entire menu is dessert: custard in cups and cones, concretes, sundaes, shakes, malts, floats, and take-home containers. Most locations are walk-up and drive-thru only, with little or no indoor seating, which is part of the charm — people order at the window, then eat their concrete sitting on the tailgate or on the curb on a summer night.
Andy’s Custard Menu Overview
The menu breaks down into nine main groups. Concretes are the signature item and the bestseller. Jackhammers are concretes with a drilled center filled with hot fudge, caramel, or another pourable topping. Sundaes and splits are the classic sit-down-style desserts. Shakes, malts, freezes, and old-fashioned sodas make up the drinks side. Cups and cones are the simplest way to taste the custard itself. Andy’s Anywhere is the take-home range of pints, quarts, and quart combos. Caramel apples and Italian ice round out the seasonal and lighter options.
Here is the whole menu at a glance, with the typical reported price range for each category. Detailed tables for every item follow in the sections below.
| Menu Category | What You Get | Typical Reported Price |
|---|---|---|
| Concretes | Vanilla or chocolate custard blended thick with mix-ins | $6.69–$6.99 |
| Jackhammers | A concrete drilled and center-filled with fudge or caramel | $7.19–$7.39 |
| Sundaes | Custard with toppings, whipped cream, and a cherry | $6.99–$7.39 |
| Splits | Banana splits and turtle splits | $7.99–$8.29 |
| Malts & Shakes | Blended custard drinks | $5.79–$5.99 |
| Freezes, Floats & Sodas | Old-fashioned soda-shop drinks | $4.79–$5.49 |
| Cups & Cones | Plain custard in a cup or cone | $5.29 |
| Andy’s Anywhere (take-home) | Pints, quarts, Pick 6, Quart Combo | $5.99–$12.99 |
| Caramel Apples | Hand-dipped seasonal apples | $5.99–$6.49 |
Prices are reported ranges from November 2026 menu listings. Your local store may charge more or less — franchise pricing varies by market, and delivery apps such as DoorDash typically list higher prices than the in-store menu.
Andy’s Concretes Menu With Prices
The concrete is the item Andy’s is famous for, and it is where most first-time visitors should start. A concrete is vanilla or chocolate frozen custard blended with your choice of mix-ins — candy, cookies, nuts, fruit, fudge — until it is so thick the server hands it to you upside down to prove it will not fall out. There are more than 54,000 possible flavor combinations, according to the company, but the named concretes below are the house signatures that appear on menus everywhere.
| Concrete | What’s In It | Reported Price | Calories |
|---|---|---|---|
| BootDaddy Concrete | Vanilla custard, Oreo cookies, crème caramel, hot fudge | $6.99 | 930 |
| Triple Chocolate Concrete | Chocolate custard with chocolate mix-ins | $6.79 | 980 |
| Ooey Gooey Concrete | Vanilla custard, Heath bar, crème caramel, almonds | $6.99 | 960 |
| Snowmonster Concrete | Vanilla custard with white chocolate and cookie mix-ins | $6.89 | 910 |
| Butter Pecan Concrete | Vanilla custard, fresh roasted pecans, butterscotch | $6.79 | 890 |
| Mint Chip Concrete | Vanilla custard, mint, chocolate chips | $6.69 | 860 |
| Jitterbug Concrete | Vanilla custard, espresso and chocolate mix-ins | $6.89 | 940 |
| Strawberry & Oreo Concrete | Vanilla custard, strawberries, Oreo pieces | $6.79 | 900 |
| Choc-o-Rocko Concrete | Chocolate custard with chocolate cookie and candy mix-ins | $6.99 | 970 |
| Cherry Bash Concrete | Vanilla custard, cherries, chocolate | $6.69 | 880 |
| Andy’s Custom Concrete | Your choice of topping blended into vanilla or chocolate custard | $3.89–$5.69 (by size, older listings) | Varies |
Two things are worth knowing about concrete pricing. First, older menu listings from 2024 and early 2025 show lower prices — for example, a custom concrete listed at $3.89 small, $4.79 medium, and $5.69 large — while the most recent 2026 listings put named concretes around $6.69–$6.99. Prices have clearly risen, and the older numbers no longer reflect what you will pay. Second, concrete sizes are not always printed on the menu board; many stores serve concretes in small, medium, and large, and the price moves with the size. If you are watching your budget, a small concrete is plenty — reviewers consistently note that even the small is a generous portion.
If you can only try one concrete, the BootDaddy is the safest pick: Oreo, caramel, and hot fudge over vanilla custard is the combination Andy’s is most associated with. The Butter Pecan is the pick for people who want something less sweet, since the roasted pecans and butterscotch keep it nutty rather than sugary. And the Triple Chocolate is the one to order if you want the richest, heaviest dessert on the menu — at a reported 980 calories, it is not a light snack.
What Is a Jackhammer? Andy’s Jackhammers Menu
The Jackhammer is Andy’s own invention, and the name is even trademarked. It starts as a concrete — custard blended with mix-ins — and then a hole is “drilled” down the middle and filled with a pourable topping such as hot fudge or caramel. The idea came from Andy Kuntz himself, who wanted more topping in the center of his concrete instead of only on top. The result is that every spoonful hits a gooey core, which is why Jackhammers tend to outsell the sundaes, according to the company’s own staff.
| Jackhammer | What’s In It | Reported Price | Calories |
|---|---|---|---|
| James Brownie Funky Jackhammer | Vanilla custard, house-baked brownie pieces, peanut butter, filled with hot fudge | $7.29 | 1,090 |
| Rico Suave Jackhammer | Vanilla custard with caramel and pecan mix-ins, filled with caramel | $7.19 | 1,020 |
| The Jackhammer | Your favorite one-topping concrete, drilled and filled with the topping of your choice | $7.39 | 1,120 |
The James Brownie Funky Jackhammer is the single most popular item at Andy’s, according to multiple store managers quoted in press coverage — a brownie-and-peanut-butter concrete with a hot fudge core. It is also the heaviest item on the menu at a reported 1,090 calories, so it is best shared or saved for a real treat day. Turning any concrete into a Jackhammer costs only a small upcharge at most stores — one review put it at about $0.49 extra — which makes it an easy upgrade if you already know your favorite concrete.
Andy’s Sundaes and Splits Menu
Sundaes at Andy’s are built on the same fresh custard, topped with hot fudge, caramel, strawberries, nuts, whipped cream, and a cherry. They are a little lighter than the concretes in texture — the custard is scooped, not blended — but they are no lighter in calories.
| Sundae or Split | What’s In It | Reported Price | Calories |
|---|---|---|---|
| Andy’s Ozark Turtle Sundae | Vanilla custard, hot fudge, caramel, roasted pecans | $7.19 | 980 |
| The Original Straw-Ana Sundae | Vanilla custard, fresh strawberries and banana | $6.99 | 860 |
| Hot Fudge Sundae with Pecans | Vanilla custard, hot fudge, roasted pecans | $7.29 | 1,010 |
| Stolen Brownie Sundae | Vanilla custard, brownie pieces, hot fudge | $7.39 | 1,080 |
| Tin Roof Sundae | Vanilla custard, chocolate, peanuts | $7.19 | 960 |
| Andy’s Banana Split | Fresh banana, three scoops of custard, fudge, strawberry, pineapple, whipped cream, nuts, cherry | $7.99 | 980 |
| Andy’s Turtle Split | Banana split with turtle toppings — fudge, caramel, pecans | $8.29 | 1,080 |
| Andy’s Custom Sundae | Your choice of custard and toppings | $3.64 (older listing) | Varies |
The Ozark Turtle is the house signature sundae and the one most regulars recommend to newcomers. The Straw-Ana is the lighter, fruitier option — fresh strawberries and banana over vanilla custard — and at a reported 860 calories it is one of the lower-calorie choices among the named desserts. The banana split is the best value for sharing: at a reported $7.99 it is cheaper than two small concretes and easily feeds two people.

Andy’s Malts, Shakes, Floats and Drinks
The drinks side of the Andy’s Custard menu is really a second dessert menu. Malts and shakes are made from the same frozen custard, blended thick with malt powder or mix-ins, while the old-fashioned sodas, freezes, and floats come from the Soda Shoppe side of the brand.
| Drink | Reported Price | Calories |
|---|---|---|
| Malts | $5.99 | 760 |
| Shakes | $5.79 | 710 |
| Old-Fashioned Freezes | $5.49 | 620 |
| Old-Fashioned Sodas | $4.99 | 390 |
| Floats (root beer, Coke, cream soda) | $5.29 | 500–540 |
| Zarlingo’s Italian Ice | $4.49 | 250 |
| Yummy Latte | $4.99 | 320 |
| Root Beer Float | $5.29 | 520 |
| Cream Soda Freeze | $5.49 | 620 |
| Double Double Malt | $6.79 | 1,020 |
| Birthday Shake | $6.29 | 890 |
| Choco Express Shake | $6.49 | 940 |
| Strawberry Oreo Cookie Shake | $6.49 | 960 |
| Iced Lattes (chocolate caramel, chocolate fudge, vanilla caramel, vanilla fudge) | $5.29–$5.49 | 390–440 |
| Fresh Brewed Iced Tea | $2.79 | 10 |
| Soft Drinks | $2.49 | 140 |
| Sprecher Soda / Bottled Sprecher Root Beer or Cream Soda | $2.99–$3.49 | 180–210 |
The Double Double Malt deserves a warning label: at a reported 1,020 calories it is essentially a concrete in a cup, and it is the heaviest drink on the menu. The root beer float is the classic pick and the best value in the drinks section — real frozen custard instead of plain ice cream, for a reported $5.29. If you want something genuinely light, the iced tea at a reported $2.79 and 10 calories is the only truly low-calorie drink on the board; everything else is dessert first and drink second.
The iced lattes are a newer addition and an easy miss — espresso, ice, and chilled milk in chocolate caramel, chocolate fudge, vanilla caramel, and vanilla fudge flavors, at a reported $5.29–$5.49. They pair well with a concrete if you want a caffeine hit with your dessert, and they are one of the few items on the menu that works as a morning stop.
Cups, Cones and Toppings
If you want to judge Andy’s on the custard itself rather than the mix-ins, order a cup or a cone. A custom cup or custom cone of vanilla or chocolate custard is listed at a reported $5.29 and 480 calories. Plain custard by the scoop in a cup is listed from around $1.94 for a small in older price lists to higher prices in 2026 listings, which is another sign of how much prices have moved — always check the board at your store.
Cones come in cake, waffle, and waffle bowl styles. You can add any topping to a cup or cone: hot fudge, caramel, chocolate syrup, sprinkles, cookie crumbles, candies, fresh fruit, and nuts are standard, while premium toppings such as cheesecake pieces, Heath Bar, roasted pecans, and cookie dough may carry an extra charge. A few toppings, including brownie pieces and espresso, are not available on sundaes at some stores. If you are building a custom concrete, the topping list is your playground — with more than 54,000 combinations possible, no two custom concretes need to be the same.
Andy’s Anywhere: Pints, Quarts and Take-Home Treats
Andy’s Anywhere is the take-home range, and it is the smartest buy on the menu if you are feeding a family. Instead of paying per cup at the window, you take custard home in pints and quarts and serve it yourself.
| Take-Home Item | Reported Price | Calories |
|---|---|---|
| Pick 6 (six half-pints) | $6.49 | 620 |
| Pints and Quarts (vanilla or chocolate) | $5.99–$10.99 | 540–1,960 |
| Specialty Pint Flavors | $6.99 | 760 |
| Quart Combo | $12.99 | 2,040 |
| Andy’s Frozen Custard Bar (4-pack) | $9.99 (older listing) | Varies |
Specialty pint flavors rotate and have included chocolate chip cookie dough, mint chocolate chip, and butter pecan. The Quart Combo — a quart of custard plus toppings — is built for parties and is the best per-serving value on the menu. Note that delivery listings show higher take-home prices than in-store menus: DoorDash listings for one Arizona store showed pints at $6.83 and quarts at $10.07, plus delivery fees, so buying at the window is cheaper when you can.
Seasonal Menu: Fall, Winter, Spring and Summer
Andy’s runs seasonal treats all year, and the seasonal menu is the main reason regulars keep coming back. The fall lineup for 2026 ran through November 25, 2026, headlined by the Pumpkin Pie Concrete — a whole slice of pumpkin pie baked fresh daily in each store, blended into vanilla frozen custard — at a typical reported price of about $6.29 small, $7.29 medium, and $8.54 large, with a pumpkin pie quart at around $8.99. The fall menu also featured a S’mores Jackhammer with hot fudge, graham cracker, and a marshmallow crème center, and hand-dipped caramel apples in Classic, Reese’s Pieces, and Pecan flavors at roughly $7.69 each in some listings, though other listings put caramel apples at $5.99–$6.49 — another case where prices vary by store, so confirm locally.
Other seasons bring their own headliners. Spring features strawberry shortcake, blueberry, and blackberry treats. Summer brings peach and key lime pie concretes. Winter brings apple pie, candy cane, Andy Nog, and the Cookie Casanova — a concrete built around a freshly baked chocolate chip cookie. Seasonal items are limited-time only, and flavors can differ by location, so if a seasonal concrete is the reason for your visit, check that your store still has it before you drive over.
Andy’s Custard Nutrition and Calories
Nothing on the Andy’s menu is a health food, and the chain does not hide that. A plain small cup of vanilla custard is reported at about 200 calories per 4-ounce serving, which is reasonable on its own — but a named concrete lands in the 860–980 calorie range, a Jackhammer crosses 1,000 calories, and a Quart Combo is reported at 2,040 calories for the whole container. The table below ranks the most popular items from lightest to heaviest so you can make an informed choice.
| Item | Reported Calories |
|---|---|
| Fresh Brewed Iced Tea | 10 |
| Zarlingo’s Italian Ice | 250 |
| Soft Drinks | 140 |
| Vanilla custard, small cup (approx.) | 200 (per 4 oz) |
| Custom cup / cone | 480 |
| Floats | 500–540 |
| Shakes | 710 |
| Malts | 760 |
| Mint Chip Concrete | 860 |
| Straw-Ana Sundae | 860 |
| Butter Pecan Concrete | 890 |
| BootDaddy Concrete | 930 |
| Triple Chocolate Concrete | 980 |
| Banana Split | 980 |
| Double Double Malt | 1,020 |
| James Brownie Funky Jackhammer | 1,090 |
For dietary restrictions, the news is mixed. Andy’s custard is built on milk, cream, sugar, and egg yolks, and there is no dairy-free or vegan custard base on the standard menu — the machines are dedicated to dairy custard. The one reliably dairy-free option is Zarlingo’s Italian Ice, served in a plain cup. Some locations offer sorbet seasonally, but availability varies and is not guaranteed. Gluten-free options are limited too: many toppings and cones contain gluten, so ask staff at your store about current choices. Full nutrition information is not published uniformly; the calorie figures in this guide come from menu-tracking sites, and your store can advise on ingredients and allergens for specific items.
Andy’s Custard Prices: What to Expect in 2026
So what should you actually budget? For one person ordering a named concrete or sundae, expect roughly $7–$8 before tax at most stores in 2026, based on the latest listings. A shake or malt runs roughly $5.79–$5.99. A plain cup or cone is around $5.29. A family of four ordering concretes should budget roughly $28–$32 before tax, and a take-home Quart Combo at a reported $12.99 is the cheapest way to serve a group.
The biggest price trap is comparing old blog posts with current menus. Prices from 2024 listings — a small custom concrete at $3.89, a banana split at $5.79–$6.29 — no longer match 2026 reality, where the same items are listed $2–$3 higher. Delivery apps add their own markup on top: the same pint that costs about $5.99 in store was listed at $6.83 on DoorDash for one location. If a price in this guide looks different from the board at your store, the board is right — franchise pricing varies by location, and prices change without notice.
Locations, Hours and How to Order
Andy’s has 192 locations in 15 states, concentrated in Missouri and Texas, with stores across the South and Midwest. The official store locator is on the Andy’s website at eatandys.com, and it is the only reliable way to check whether a seasonal item is available near you.
Hours are fairly consistent across the chain. Most stores open at 11:00 a.m. and close at 11:00 p.m. Sunday through Thursday, staying open until 11:30 p.m. on Friday and Saturday. That pattern is confirmed by the official Springfield, Missouri, store listing, but individual stores vary — some close earlier, and holiday hours differ. Both Andy’s and its competitors close on Christmas Day, and Andy’s also closes on Christmas Eve, so plan around the holidays. Always check your local store’s hours before visiting, especially on holidays.
Ordering is simple: most locations are walk-up and drive-thru, with online and mobile ordering available at many stores. Delivery depends on the location and the delivery services it works with. Andy’s also sells gift cards, and the chain runs a rewards program — reviewers mention surprise free concretes for members. If you are ordering for a party or celebration, ask your local store about catering and larger take-home orders, since availability varies by location.
What to Order at Andy’s: Our Picks
If you are visiting for the first time, here is the short list. First-timers should order the James Brownie Funky Jackhammer — it is the most popular item on the menu for a reason, and the hot fudge core is the full Andy’s experience. If you want the classic concrete without the extra weight, the BootDaddy is the signature pick. For something fruitier and lighter, the Straw-Ana Sundae is the best choice. For a group, skip individual cups and buy a Quart Combo to share. And if you visit in the fall, the Pumpkin Pie Concrete is worth the trip on its own — it disappears from the menu after November 25.
For value, the small concrete is the sweet spot: it is a generous portion at the lowest price, and the upgrade to a Jackhammer costs only a small upcharge at most stores. For the lightest option that still feels like Andy’s, a small vanilla cup with fresh strawberries gives you the fresh-hourly custard without the 900-calorie commitment. If you love frozen desserts generally, compare the experience with the dessert menus at other chains — see our guides to Burger King desserts and the Burger King milkshake for a sense of how a custard specialist differs from a fast-food dessert menu, and the full Burger King menu for a broader price comparison.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the most popular item on the Andy’s Custard menu?
The James Brownie Funky Jackhammer is the most popular item at Andy’s, according to store managers quoted in press coverage. It is vanilla frozen custard blended with house-baked brownie pieces and peanut butter, then drilled and filled with hot fudge, at a reported price of $7.29 and 1,090 calories.
How much is a concrete at Andy’s?
Named concretes are typically reported at $6.69–$6.99 in 2026 listings, with prices varying by size and location. Older listings show lower prices, so expect around $7 for a regular concrete at most stores. A small custom concrete was listed at $3.89 in older price lists, but that figure no longer reflects 2026 pricing — confirm the price at your local store.
What is a Jackhammer at Andy’s?
A Jackhammer is Andy’s trademarked signature: a concrete that is drilled with a hole down the middle and filled with a pourable topping such as hot fudge or caramel. The idea came from Andy Kuntz, who wanted more topping in the center of his concrete. Jackhammers are reported at $7.19–$7.39.
What are Andy’s Frozen Custard hours?
Most Andy’s locations are open 11:00 a.m. to 11:00 p.m. Sunday through Thursday, and until 11:30 p.m. on Friday and Saturday. Hours vary by store, and Andy’s closes on Christmas Day and Christmas Eve, so check your local store before visiting.
Does Andy’s have dairy-free options?
Andy’s does not offer a dairy-free or vegan custard base on its standard menu, because the custard is made from milk, cream, sugar, and egg yolks. The dairy-free option is Zarlingo’s Italian Ice, served in a plain cup. Some locations may offer sorbet seasonally — ask your local store.
How many calories are in an Andy’s concrete?
Named concretes are reported at roughly 860–980 calories, depending on the flavor and size. The Mint Chip Concrete is among the lightest at a reported 860 calories, while the Triple Chocolate Concrete is reported at 980 calories. A plain small cup of vanilla custard is about 200 calories per 4-ounce serving.
Can you order Andy’s online or for delivery?
Online and mobile ordering is available at most Andy’s locations, and delivery depends on the location and the delivery services it works with. Delivery listings typically show higher prices than the in-store menu, so ordering at the window or for pickup is usually cheaper.
What is the cheapest item on the Andy’s Custard menu?
The cheapest items are the simple drinks: soft drinks at a reported $2.49 and fresh brewed iced tea at $2.79. Among desserts, a plain small cup of custard is the lowest-priced option, while named concretes start at a reported $6.69. Prices vary by location.
Does Andy’s sell pints and quarts to take home?
Yes. Andy’s Anywhere is the take-home range: pints and quarts of vanilla or chocolate custard at a reported $5.99–$10.99, specialty pint flavors at $6.99, a Pick 6 of half-pints at $6.49, and a Quart Combo at $12.99. Specialty flavors rotate seasonally.
Is Andy’s Frozen Custard only in Missouri?
No. Andy’s started in Osage Beach, Missouri, in 1986, but it now has 192 locations across 15 states, including Texas, Arizona, Florida, Georgia, Illinois, Kansas, and the Carolinas. Use the official store locator at eatandys.com to find the nearest location.






