Domino’s menu is big enough that a first order can feel like a gamble — specialty pizzas, five crusts, chicken, sandwiches, pasta, desserts — and the house classics aren’t always the best choice. Whether you’re ordering for the first time, trying to impress a group, or just tired of defaulting to pepperoni, this guide picks the Domino’s items actually worth your money in 2026, plus the viral pan-pizza order fans keep reordering.
The short version for the indecisive: a large Handmade Pan ExtravaganZZa feeds a group, a medium Hand Tossed Ultimate Pepperoni is the safe solo play, and 8-piece boneless chicken + Stuffed Cheesy Bread is the add-on combo regulars swear by. If you care about price first, read our Domino’s deals guide before you order — and the full price breakdown lives in our Domino’s menu with prices (2026).
The 10 Best Domino’s Pizzas, Ranked for First-Timers
- ExtravaganZZa (Handmade Pan). The loaded flagship — pepperoni, ham, sausage, beef, onions, peppers, mushrooms, black olives. On pan crust it eats like a meal, and it’s the default answer for a group with mixed tastes.
- Ultimate Pepperoni. Double pepperoni under and over the cheese so the edges crisp up. If you only know Domino’s as “the cheap delivery place,” this is the pie that updates that impression.
- Philly Cheese Steak. Shaved steak, peppers, onions, mushrooms with a mozzarella–provolone blend. The sleeper specialty pick — savory without being heavy.
- MeatZZa. Four-meat pie (pepperoni, ham, sausage, beef) with zero vegetables to negotiate with. Simple, salty, and great on thin crust.
- Buffalo Chicken. Buffalo-sauced chicken and onions on a cheese blend. A solid pick for people who wish pizza had more going on than cheese and red sauce.
- Memphis BBQ Chicken. BBQ sauce base, grilled chicken, onions. Sweet-smoky instead of acidic — the pick for BBQ fans who don’t want wings.
- Wisconsin 6-Cheese. Six cheeses with no meat and no vegetables. Order it when you want the crust and cheese to carry the whole thing.
- Pacific Veggie. The best vegetarian option: mushrooms, peppers, olives, roasted red peppers, tomatoes, onions. Better on Crunchy Thin than on pan.
- Honolulu Hawaiian. Ham and pineapple plus bacon and roasted red peppers — the extra toppings fix the too-sweet problem plain Hawaiian can have.
- Spinach & Feta. Alfredo base, spinach, feta, parmesan, mushrooms. The “I want something different” order; pairs well with the garlic dipping cup.
On DoorDash, the most-ordered items at US stores skew the same way — Build Your Own, Ultimate Pepperoni, and Wisconsin 6-Cheese lead, which says the crowd favorites hold up nationwide.
The Viral Domino’s Pan Pizza Order
This build-your-own combo went viral on TikTok/Lemon8 with thousands of reposts because it replaces the whole flavor profile of a normal Domino’s pie. Here’s exactly how to order it:
- Start Build Your Own Pizza on dominos.com or the app.
- Choose Handmade Pan crust — the buttery, crispy-edged base matters.
- Swap the sauce to Garlic Parmesan Sauce (skip the tomato sauce entirely) and select Extra.
- Under cheese, choose the Cheddar Cheese Blend and select Extra.
- Add Philly Steak and Bacon as toppings.
- Add a garlic dipping cup on the side — reviewers call it mandatory.
Expect to pay more than a standard specialty pizza since extra sauce, extra cheese, and premium toppings each add up — worth it as a treat, but run it through the deals page first.
Best Non-Pizza Items Worth Adding
- 8-Piece Boneless Chicken (~$9.99). Breaded chicken chunks tossed in your sauce of choice. Frequently drops to $6.99 in the Mix & Match deal — that’s the price to wait for.
- Stuffed Cheesy Bread (~$7.49). The single best-selling side at the chain for years: breadsticks stuffed with cheese, dusted with seasoning. A Mix & Match qualifier too.
- Chicken Bacon Ranch Sandwich (~$8.50). The strongest of the oven-baked sandwiches — the bread bakes up like a pan-pizza edge. Good solo lunch.
- Chicken Alfredo Pasta (~$8.99–$9.99). Penne in a creamy alfredo with chicken, baked in the dish. Heavier than it looks; split it.
- Parmesan Bread Twists (~$6.79). The cheap add-on that punches above its price — cheesy, garlicky, shareable.
Best Desserts at Domino’s
- Chocolate Lava Crunch Cake (~$6.99). The signature dessert: a baked chocolate cake with a molten center. Order it; there’s no second place.
- Marbled Cookie Brownie (~$6.99). Half cookie, half brownie, baked in a pan. A Mix & Match qualifier — pairing it with a pizza for $6.99 is one of the best dessert values in delivery.
- Cinnamon Bread Twists (~$6.79). The light dessert option: sweet, cinnamon-dusted twists with icing for dipping.
What to Order by Occasion
| Occasion | The Order | Why It Works |
|---|---|---|
| First time, solo | Medium Hand Tossed Ultimate Pepperoni + garlic dip | Shows the chain at its best; leftovers reheat well (see how to reheat pizza) |
| Date night | Medium specialty pizza + Chicken Alfredo pasta + Lava Crunch Cakes | Mix of familiar and shareable; use Mix & Match for two items at $6.99 each |
| Family dinner (4–6) | 2 large pizzas (Mix & Match) + oven-baked sandwiches + cookie brownie | ~$14 for the two pizzas before sides; covers picky eaters |
| Game night (6–8) | 2 large specialty pizzas + 8-pc wings + stuffed cheesy bread + 2-liter | The $19.99 Perfect Combo covers most of this in one click |
| Lighter option | Medium Crunchy Thin Pacific Veggie + garden salad | Thin crust cuts roughly 100 calories per slice vs. hand tossed; check MOD Pizza nutrition for comparison |
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the best thing to order at Domino’s for the first time?
A large Handmade Pan ExtravaganZZa if you’re feeding people, or a medium Hand Tossed Ultimate Pepperoni if it’s just you. Both show off what Domino’s does best — and add Stuffed Cheesy Bread if you want the classic side.
What is the viral Domino’s pizza order?
Handmade Pan crust, garlic parmesan sauce (extra, no tomato sauce), cheddar cheese blend (extra), Philly steak, and bacon, with a garlic dipping cup on the side. It went viral on TikTok and Lemon8 in 2024–2025.
What is the most popular Domino’s pizza?
Ultimate Pepperoni is consistently among the most-ordered pizzas (delivery platforms rank it top alongside build-your-own and Wisconsin 6-Cheese), with ExtravaganZZa close behind for group orders.
What should I order at Domino’s besides pizza?
The 8-piece boneless chicken, Stuffed Cheesy Bread, Chicken Bacon Ranch sandwich, and Chocolate Lava Crunch Cake are the non-pizza items reviewers keep coming back to.
What is the best crust at Domino’s?
Handmade Pan for indulgence (thick, buttery, crispy edges), Hand Tossed as the all-rounder classic, Crunchy Thin for lighter eating, and Brooklyn Style for big foldable New York–style slices.
What is the cheapest good order at Domino’s?
Two Mix & Match items at $6.99 each — e.g., a medium 2-topping pizza plus boneless chicken for $13.98 before tax. For solo carryout, the $7.99 carryout deal is hard to beat.
What should vegetarians order at Domino’s?
The Pacific Veggie specialty pizza is the strongest vegetarian pick (best on thin crust), plus the Wisconsin 6-Cheese for cheese lovers and the Spinach & Feta for something different.
What desserts are worth it at Domino’s?
The Chocolate Lava Crunch Cake is the must-try. The Marbled Cookie Brownie is the value pick (it’s a Mix & Match qualifier), and Cinnamon Bread Twists are the lighter sweet option.
How do I order for a large group at Domino’s?
For 6–8 people: two large specialty pizzas, wings, and a side — the $19.99 Perfect Combo covers most of it. For 10+, call ahead; stores can handle large orders with notice.
Is Domino’s pan pizza better than hand tossed?
Different, not strictly better: pan is thick, buttery, and indulgent with crisp caramelized edges; hand tossed is the classic medium crust. Try pan once (it’s the viral-order crust) and decide from there.
The Bottom Line
You can’t go wrong with an ExtravaganZZa on pan crust for a crowd or an Ultimate Pepperoni for yourself — and the viral garlic-parm pan build is genuinely worth trying once. Add Stuffed Cheesy Bread and a Lava Crunch Cake and you’ve covered the Domino’s experience. Whatever you pick, run it through dominos.com‘s deals tab first: our Domino’s deals guide shows how to get most of these picks for less.
Related: Domino’s Pizza Menu With Prices (2026) · Domino’s Pizza Deals & Coupons (2026) · How to Reheat Pizza · MOD Pizza Nutrition & Calories
